Etsy vs Amazon: which takes less from a $50 order?
On the same $50 item + $5 shipping, Etsy takes $5.68 and you keep $49.32. Amazon takes $7.50 in referral fees alone, and $10.83 all-in with FBA. The headline rates hide the real difference: Etsy charges its percentage fees on the item price plus shipping, while Amazon's referral fee is charged on the item price only.
The fee base difference, in one paragraph
Etsy advertises 6.5% and Amazon advertises 15%, so Amazon looks more than twice as expensive. It is not, because the two percentages are charged on different amounts. Etsy's 6.5% transaction fee and 3% processing fee both apply to the item price plus shipping, and the $0.20 listing fee sits on top. Amazon's 15% referral fee applies to the item price only, and shipping is handled separately: with FBM you pay the carrier yourself, with FBA you pay Amazon's fulfillment fee. Once you run the same order through both, the gap is real but much smaller than the headlines suggest.
The math: the same $50 order three ways
The buyer pays $55 in total: a $50 item plus $5 shipping.
- Etsy: $5.68. Listing $0.20, plus transaction fee 6.5% of $55 = $3.58, plus processing 3% of $55 = $1.65 + $0.25 = $1.90. Total: $0.20 + $3.58 + $1.90 = $5.68. You keep $55.00 - $5.68 = $49.32. That is 10.3% of the $55 the buyer paid.
- Amazon FBM (you ship it): $7.50 in Amazon fees. Referral fee 15% of the $50 item price = $7.50. No fulfillment fee. You keep $55.00 - $7.50 = $47.50 before shipping costs, and after paying roughly $5 to ship it yourself, about $42.50. That is 13.6% of the $55 in referral fees alone.
- Amazon FBA (Amazon ships it): $10.83. Referral fee 15% of $50 = $7.50, plus fulfillment fee $3.22 for a small standard item, plus the 3.5% fuel surcharge on the fulfillment fee: 3.5% of $3.22 = $0.11. Total: $7.50 + $3.22 + $0.11 = $10.83. You keep $55.00 - $10.83 = $44.17. That is 19.7% of the $55. From 15 October 2026 to 14 January 2027, add the holiday peak fee of about $0.32 a unit, which takes the total to $11.15.
| Etsy | Amazon FBM | Amazon FBA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listing / referral fee | $0.20 + 6.5% of $55 = $3.78 | 15% of $50 = $7.50 | 15% of $50 = $7.50 |
| Payment processing | 3% of $55 + $0.25 = $1.90 | Included in referral fee | Included in referral fee |
| Fulfillment / shipping | You ship it (about $5) | You ship it (about $5) | $3.22 + $0.11 fuel surcharge |
| Total Amazon / Etsy fees | $5.68 | $7.50 | $10.83 |
| You keep (before your shipping cost) | $49.32 | $47.50 | $44.17 |
| You keep (after ~$5 shipping, Etsy and FBM) | ~$44.32 | ~$42.50 | $44.17 |
Read the last row carefully: once you pay to ship the item yourself, Etsy and FBA end up almost level on this order, about $44.32 against $44.17. FBA looks expensive only until you count your own packing time, the box, and the trip to the post office.
Why Amazon's headline rate misleads
Take a $50 item with $8 shipping, so the buyer pays $58. Etsy takes $0.20 + 6.5% of $58 + 3% of $58 + $0.25 = $5.96, which is 10.28% of the $58. Amazon's referral fee is 15% of the $50 item price = $7.50, which is 12.93% of the $58. So Etsy advertises 6.5% and charges about 10.28% effective, while Amazon advertises 15% and charges about 12.93% effective on the same order. The fee base is the whole story: Etsy charges on item plus shipping, Amazon charges the referral fee on the item only.
What about the 30% to 40% FBA figure?
You will see it quoted everywhere: Amazon all-in with FBA runs 30% to 40% of the sale. That is true, but it is not just Amazon's fees. On a heavier item the fulfillment fee alone climbs: a large standard item of 2 to 3 lb costs $6.10 to fulfill, plus $0.21 fuel surcharge, so with the $7.50 referral fee the Amazon total is $13.81, or 25.1% of this $55 order. Storage fees, prep, advertising and returns push a typical all-in FBA cost to 30% to 40%. On a small, light item the pure Amazon fees are about 20%. The 30% to 40% figure is a planning budget, not a fee schedule.
The verdict
- On fees alone, Etsy wins. $5.68 against $7.50 in referral fees, or $10.83 all-in with FBA, on the same $50 order.
- FBM is the cheapest Amazon route if you can pack and ship cheaply yourself, because the referral fee is the same either way and there is no fulfillment fee.
- FBA is worth it for the Prime badge and hands-off fulfilment, not for the fees. Once you count your own shipping cost and packing time, FBA and Etsy land within cents of each other on a $50 order.
- Watch the category. The 15% referral fee is the most common rate, but electronics are 8% and clothing and shoes are 17%, so the answer changes by category.
Run your own prices in the Etsy fee calculator, the Amazon FBA calculator and the Amazon referral fee calculator. For the full FBA fee table, see Amazon FBA fees explained.
Fees checked: November 2026
Fees last checked November 2026 against Etsy's and Amazon's published US rates. FBA fulfillment $3.22 to $6.10 for standard-size items, 3.5% fuel surcharge since 17 April 2026, holiday peak fee about $0.32 from 15 October 2026 to 14 January 2027. Estimates only. FeeWisely is not affiliated with Etsy, Inc. or Amazon.com, Inc.
Questions sellers ask
Which is cheaper, Etsy or Amazon?
On fees alone, Etsy. On a $50 item + $5 shipping, Etsy takes $5.68. Amazon takes $7.50 in referral fees alone, and $10.83 all-in with FBA, using a small standard item. Amazon only wins on reach, not on fees.
Does Amazon charge fees on shipping?
Not the referral fee: Amazon's 15% referral fee is charged on the item price only, while Etsy's fees are charged on the item price plus shipping. With FBA, Amazon charges the fulfillment fee instead, which covers the shipping to the buyer.
Is FBA or FBM cheaper?
The referral fee is the same either way, 15% of the item price. FBA adds a fulfillment fee of $3.22 to $6.10 for standard-size items plus a 3.5% fuel surcharge, so FBM is cheaper per order if you can pack and ship cheaply yourself. FBA buys you the Prime badge and hands-off fulfilment.
What is the Amazon referral fee?
15% of the item price in most categories, with a $0.30 minimum per item. Electronics are 8%, clothing and shoes 17%, and jewelry 20%. It applies whether you use FBA or fulfill orders yourself.