Etsy vs eBay: which takes less from a $50 sale?
On the same $50 item + $5 shipping, Etsy takes $5.68 and you keep $49.32, while eBay takes $7.88 and you keep $47.12. Etsy wins by $2.20 on a normal sale. eBay only wins when most of your Etsy sales come through Offsite Ads, or when you sell in one of eBay's low-fee categories.
The two fee structures
- Etsy (US seller): $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing on the item price plus shipping. The wild card is Offsite Ads: 12% of the sale for shops that earned under $10,000 in the last 12 months (you can opt out), and 15% for shops that earned $10,000 or more (you cannot opt out).
- eBay (US seller): 13.6% final value fee on the item price plus shipping, plus a $0.40 per-order fee on sales over $10 ($0.30 on sales of $10 or less). There is no per-sale listing fee for most sellers, so the final value fee is the cost that matters on every sale. A few categories pay much less, covered below.
The math: one $50 item + $5 shipping
The buyer pays $55 in total. Here is where every cent of it goes, step by step.
- Etsy: $5.68. Listing $0.20, plus transaction fee 6.5% of $55 = $3.58, plus processing 3% of $55 = $1.65 + $0.25 = $1.90. Total: $0.20 + $3.58 + $1.90 = $5.68. You keep $55.00 - $5.68 = $49.32.
- eBay: $7.88. Final value fee 13.6% of $55 = $7.48, plus the $0.40 per-order fee. Total: $7.48 + $0.40 = $7.88. You keep $55.00 - $7.88 = $47.12.
Etsy leaves you $2.20 more on this sale. The gap is the fee base and the headline rate: eBay's 13.6% is charged on the whole $55, while Etsy's stack adds up to about 10.3% of the $55.
| Item price | Buyer pays (item + $5 shipping) | Etsy fees | You keep (Etsy) | eBay fees | You keep (eBay) | Etsy wins by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10 | $15.00 | $1.88 | $13.12 | $2.44 | $12.56 | $0.56 |
| $25 | $30.00 | $3.30 | $26.70 | $4.48 | $25.52 | $1.18 |
| $50 | $55.00 | $5.68 | $49.32 | $7.88 | $47.12 | $2.20 |
| $100 | $105.00 | $10.43 | $94.57 | $14.68 | $90.32 | $4.25 |
| $300 | $305.00 | $29.43 | $275.57 | $41.88 | $263.12 | $12.45 |
Etsy wins at every price in this ladder, and the gap grows with the sale: 56 cents on a $10 item, $12.45 on a $300 item. That is because the $0.20 listing fee and the $0.25 processing fixed fee matter less as the price rises, while eBay's 13.6% keeps taking the same share.
When eBay wins: Offsite Ads
Offsite Ads is the one thing that flips this comparison. When Etsy attributes a sale to one of its ads, it adds 12% or 15% of the item price plus shipping on top of the normal fees.
- Offsite Ads at 12%: 12% of $55 = $6.60. Etsy total: $5.68 + $6.60 = $12.28. You keep $42.72. eBay's $7.88 now wins by $4.40.
- Offsite Ads at 15%: 15% of $55 = $8.25. Etsy total: $5.68 + $8.25 = $13.93. You keep $41.07. eBay wins by $6.05.
So the real question is not one sale, it is your mix of sales. Etsy starts $2.20 ahead on a normal sale. Each Offsite Ads order at 15% costs an extra $8.25, so eBay wins on average once about 27% of your orders (about 1 in 4) come through Offsite Ads at 15%. At the 12% rate the crossover is about 33% (about 1 in 3). If you are under $10,000 a year and can opt out of Offsite Ads, Etsy stays cheaper. If you are over $10,000 and cannot opt out, check what share of your orders the ads actually drive before you assume Etsy is cheaper.
When eBay wins: low-fee categories
eBay charges less than 13.6% in a few categories, and there Etsy loses outright.
- Guitars, 6.7%: on the same $50 item + $5 shipping, eBay takes 6.7% of $55 = $3.69 + $0.40 = $4.09. You keep $50.91, which beats Etsy's $49.32 by $1.59.
- Sneakers over $150, 8%: on a $200 item + $5 shipping ($205 total), eBay takes 8% of $205 = $16.40 + $0.40 = $16.80. You keep $188.20. Etsy on the same $205 takes $0.20 + 6.5% of $205 + 3% of $205 + $0.25 = $19.93, and you keep $185.07. eBay wins by $3.13.
The verdict
- On fees alone, Etsy wins for most sellers. At every price from $10 to $300, a normal Etsy sale leaves you more than the same eBay sale, and the gap grows with the price.
- Offsite Ads can erase the gap. If about 1 in 4 of your orders comes through Offsite Ads at 15%, eBay is cheaper on average. Under $10,000 a year you can opt out; over $10,000 you cannot, so watch your ad-attributed share.
- Check your category before you switch. In eBay's low-fee categories, guitars at 6.7% and sneakers over $150 at 8%, eBay wins outright even without ads.
- Fees are not the whole decision. Etsy brings built-in shoppers looking for handmade and vintage; eBay brings the biggest general audience and stronger tools for used, rare and collectible items. Pick the buyers first, then check the fees.
Run your own prices in the Etsy fee calculator and the eBay fee calculator, and read how Offsite Ads really works in the Etsy Offsite Ads guide. For the $50 sale on its own, see how much Etsy takes from a $50 sale, or compare six more platforms in the reseller fee comparison.
Fees checked: November 2026
Fees last checked November 2026 against Etsy's and eBay's published US rates. Estimates only. FeeWisely is not affiliated with Etsy, Inc. or eBay Inc.
Questions sellers ask
Which is cheaper, Etsy or eBay?
On a normal sale, Etsy. On a $50 item + $5 shipping, Etsy takes $5.68 and eBay takes $7.88 using US rates, so Etsy leaves you $2.20 more. eBay only wins when most of your Etsy sales come through Offsite Ads, or in a few low-fee categories like guitars at 6.7%.
Does eBay charge fees on shipping?
Yes. eBay's 13.6% final value fee applies to the item price plus shipping, and the $0.40 per-order fee applies on top. Etsy also charges its 6.5% transaction fee and 3% + $0.25 processing on shipping.
When does eBay beat Etsy?
When a large share of your Etsy orders comes through Offsite Ads, or when you sell in one of eBay's low-fee categories. At the 15% Offsite Ads rate, eBay wins on average once about 1 in 4 of your orders comes through Offsite Ads; at 12%, once about 1 in 3 does.
What is the Etsy Offsite Ads fee?
12% of the sale for shops that earned under $10,000 in the last 12 months, and 15% for shops that earned $10,000 or more. Shops under $10,000 can opt out; shops over $10,000 cannot.