Etsy vs Gumroad: which takes less from a digital sale?

Digital sellers ask this constantly, and the honest answer is closer than the marketing on either side suggests. Below is the per-sale fee math for digital products at $10, $25 and $50, using published US rates, plus the two catches that flip the result: Etsy's Offsite Ads and Gumroad's Discover cut.

The two fee structures

  • Etsy: $0.20 listing fee per item (charged again at every renewal and on each sale of a multi-quantity listing), 6.5% transaction fee, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing for US sellers. No shipping on digital items, so nothing stacks on top. The wild card is Offsite Ads: if Etsy attributes the sale to one of its ads, add 12% for shops under $10k/year (you can opt out) or 15% for shops over $10k/year (you cannot opt out).
  • Gumroad: no listing fee, no renewals, no monthly fee. You pay 10% + $0.50 per direct sale, that is, when the buyer comes through your own link. When a buyer finds your product through Gumroad Discover, its marketplace and recommendation system, Gumroad keeps 30% instead.

The math, side by side

One digital product, three prices. Etsy figures assume a US seller, a fresh listing fee, and no Offsite Ads attribution. Gumroad Discover is shown so you can see what marketplace discovery costs on each platform.

Sale priceEtsy feesYou keep (Etsy)Gumroad direct feesYou keep (direct)Gumroad Discover feesYou keep (Discover)
$10$0.20 + 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 = $1.40 (14.0%)$8.6010% + $0.50 = $1.50 (15.0%)$8.5030% = $3.00$7.00
$25$0.20 + 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 = $2.83 (11.3%)$22.1810% + $0.50 = $3.00 (12.0%)$22.0030% = $7.50$17.50
$50$0.20 + 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 = $5.20 (10.4%)$44.8010% + $0.50 = $5.50 (11.0%)$44.5030% = $15.00$35.00

The verdict

  • On fees alone, Etsy wins, but only just. At all three prices Etsy leaves you a little more than a direct Gumroad sale, roughly 10 to 30 cents per sale, because its 9.5% + $0.45 stack edges out Gumroad's 10% + $0.50.
  • Discovery is where both platforms get expensive. Etsy's Offsite Ads take 15% when they drive the sale; Gumroad Discover takes 30%. If buyers find you through the platform, Gumroad's discovery cut is the priciest option on this page. The difference: under $10k/year in sales you can opt out of Etsy's Offsite Ads, while Discover pricing is simply how Gumroad works.
  • Gumroad is simpler to run. No $0.20 renewals quietly billing you every four months for listings that have not sold, no fee stack to decode, and you keep your own storefront and customer emails. Etsy's counterweight is its enormous built-in shopper traffic, which most new digital sellers do not have on their own.
  • Rule of thumb: if you still need a marketplace to bring you buyers, Etsy is cheaper per sale and the traffic is the point. If you already have an audience, on social media or an email list, Gumroad direct is nearly as cheap and much simpler. Either way, avoid building a business that depends on Discover's 30%.

Run your own prices in the Etsy fee calculator, and if you sell physical or second-hand goods too, compare six more platforms in the reseller fee comparison.

Fees last checked October 2026 against Etsy's and Gumroad's published rates (US sellers). Estimates only. FeeWisely is not affiliated with Etsy, Inc. or Gumroad, Inc.

Questions sellers ask

Which is cheaper for digital products, Etsy or Gumroad?

On fees alone, Etsy is slightly cheaper at typical digital prices, using US rates and no Offsite Ads: about $1.40 on a $10 sale versus Gumroad's $1.50, $2.83 versus $3.00 on $25, and $5.20 versus $5.50 on $50. The gap is small, and an Etsy Offsite Ads fee (15%) or a Gumroad Discover sale (30%) changes the answer completely.

Does Gumroad charge a listing fee?

No. Gumroad has no listing fee and no renewals. You pay only when you sell: 10% + $0.50 on a direct sale, or 30% when the sale comes through Gumroad Discover.

What is Gumroad Discover's 30% fee?

Discover is Gumroad's built-in marketplace and recommendation system. When a buyer finds your product through Discover rather than through your own link, Gumroad keeps 30% of that sale instead of the standard 10% + $0.50.

Can Etsy end up costing more than Gumroad?

Yes. If an Etsy sale is attributed to an Offsite Ad, Etsy adds 15% on top of its normal fees, which makes that sale far pricier than a direct Gumroad sale. Unsold listings also keep renewing at $0.20 every four months on Etsy, a cost Gumroad never charges.