Printify vs Printful: which leaves more from a $29.99 shirt?

On the same $29.99 Bella + Canvas 3001 tee sold on Etsy, Printful leaves $14.77 before shipping, Printify Free leaves $15.71, and Printify Premium leaves $17.92 before its $39 a month plan. Printify wins per shirt. Whether it wins per month depends on how many shirts you sell.

The short answer

ProviderPlanProduct costEtsy feesYou keep (before shipping)
PrintfulFree$11.92$3.30$14.77
PrintifyFree$10.98$3.30$15.71
PrintifyPremium ($39/mo)$8.77$3.30$17.92

Profits above are before the cost of shipping the shirt to the buyer, which varies by provider and location and is not included. Etsy fees are on the $29.99 item price with no shipping charged; if you charge shipping, Etsy fees apply to it too.

The math, step by step

First, the Etsy fees on a $29.99 item, US seller, no shipping charged: listing fee $0.20, plus transaction fee 6.5% of $29.99 = $1.95, plus payment processing 3% of $29.99 = $0.90 + $0.25 = $1.15. Total Etsy fees: $0.20 + $1.95 + $1.15 = $3.30.

  • Printful: $29.99 - $11.92 product - $3.30 Etsy fees = $14.77.
  • Printify Free: $29.99 - $10.98 product - $3.30 Etsy fees = $15.71.
  • Printify Premium: $29.99 - $8.77 product - $3.30 Etsy fees = $17.92, before the $39 a month plan fee.

The product cost is the whole difference here. Printify's cheapest provider charges $10.98 for this tee on the Free plan and $8.77 on Premium, against Printful's $11.92. Etsy takes the same $3.30 either way.

The plans, side by side

ProviderFree planPaid planPaid plan becomes free
Printify$0 a monthPremium: $39 a month, or $299 a yearNever; the yearly plan saves about $169 a year against monthly billing
Printful$0 a monthGrowth: $24.99 a monthOnce your yearly sales reach $12,000

Printify Premium rose from $29 to $39 a month on 17 February 2026, so older guides quoting $29 are out of date. Printful Growth is cheaper per month than Printify Premium, but it discounts products rather than cutting the base price to a fixed low number, so its saving per shirt varies by product.

Break-even: how many shirts pay for Premium?

Premium saves $10.98 - $8.77 = $2.21 a shirt against the Free plan. The plan costs $39 a month, so $39 / $2.21 = 17.6 shirts. Call it about 18 shirts a month. Sell fewer than that and the Free plan leaves you more per month. Sell more and Premium pulls ahead: at 30 shirts a month, Premium saves 30 x $2.21 = $66.30 in product costs, minus the $39 plan fee, which is $27.30 a month better than Free. Printful Growth has no single break-even number because its discount varies by product; it pays for itself only if its discounts save you more than $24.99 a month.

Same company now

Printify and Printful merged in November 2024 under the parent company FYUL. They still run as separate services with separate prices, plans and product catalogs, so this comparison still matters. Do not assume a price on one carries over to the other, and do not assume a combined plan exists: there is none.

What the numbers leave out

  • Shipping to the buyer. Provider shipping varies by provider, product and destination, and it is not in the per-shirt profit above. A cheaper product with expensive shipping can lose to a dearer product with cheap shipping, so compare the delivered cost, not just the product price.
  • Print quality and range. Printful prints in-house with consistent quality control; Printify is a marketplace of independent print providers, so quality and shipping speed vary by provider. Check reviews for the provider you pick, not just the price.
  • Etsy integration. Both plug into Etsy, and both leave you paying the same Etsy fees. Your Etsy listing, mockups and customer service are the same either way.

Run your own prices in the Etsy Printify fee calculator and the Etsy print-on-demand fee calculator, and check the Etsy side in the Etsy fee calculator. For pricing the shirt itself, see Etsy pricing strategy.

Rates from Printify and Printful published pricing, checked November 2026. FeeWisely is not affiliated with Printify, Printful or FYUL.

Fees checked: November 2026

FAQs

Which is cheaper, Printify or Printful?

Per shirt, Printify. On a $29.99 Bella + Canvas 3001 tee sold on Etsy, Printful leaves $14.77 before shipping, Printify Free leaves $15.71, and Printify Premium leaves $17.92 before its $39 a month plan. Printful's product costs $11.92, Printify's $10.98 on Free and $8.77 on Premium.

How many shirts pay for Printify Premium?

About 18 shirts a month. Premium saves $2.21 a shirt against the Free plan ($10.98 minus $8.77), and $39 divided by $2.21 is 17.6 shirts. Below that, the Free plan leaves you more per month.

Did Printify and Printful merge?

Yes, in November 2024, under the parent company FYUL. They still run as separate services with separate prices, plans and product catalogs, so the comparison on this page still matters.

Is Printful Growth worth it?

It costs $24.99 a month and gives discounted product prices, and it becomes free once your yearly sales reach $12,000. It pays for itself only if the discounts save you more than $24.99 a month, which depends on your volume and products.