Etsy vs Shopify: at what sales level does Shopify win?

On a $40 average order, Etsy costs about $4.25 and Shopify costs about $1.46 plus $39 a month. The crossover is about 14 orders a month, roughly $560 in monthly sales, on the $39 a month plan. Below that, Etsy is cheaper. Above it, Shopify pulls ahead, and the gap grows fast.

The two fee structures

  • Etsy: no monthly fee. Per order you pay the $0.20 listing fee, the 6.5% transaction fee, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing, all on the order total. That works out to $0.45 + 9.5% of the order. On a $40 order: $0.45 + 9.5% of $40 = $0.45 + $3.80 = $4.25, about 10.6% of the order.
  • Shopify Basic: $39 a month on monthly billing, or $29 a month billed yearly, plus 2.9% + $0.30 card processing per transaction. With Shopify Payments there is no extra platform fee. Using another payment gateway adds up to 2% per sale. On a $40 order: 2.9% of $40 = $1.16 + $0.30 = $1.46, plus your share of the monthly plan fee.

The crossover table: $100 to $5,000 a month

Orders are monthly sales divided by the $40 average order. Etsy fees are orders x $4.25. Shopify fees are the monthly plan plus orders x $1.46.

Monthly salesOrders (at $40 avg)Etsy feesShopify fees ($39/mo plan)Shopify fees ($29/mo plan)Cheaper
$1002.5$10.63$42.65$32.65Etsy
$2506.25$26.56$48.13$38.13Etsy
$50012.5$53.13$57.25$47.25Etsy ($39 plan); Shopify ($29 plan)
$1,00025$106.25$75.50$65.50Shopify
$2,50062.5$265.63$130.25$120.25Shopify
$5,000125$531.25$221.50$211.50Shopify

At $5,000 a month in sales, Shopify on the $39 plan saves you $531.25 - $221.50 = $309.75 a month in fees. At $100 a month, the same plan costs you $32.02 a month more than Etsy.

The crossover, worked out

Shopify saves $4.25 - $1.46 = $2.79 on every order, and the plan costs $39 a month. So the crossover is $39 / $2.79 = about 14 orders a month, which is 14 x $40 = about $560 in monthly sales. Check it: at 14 orders, Etsy costs 14 x $4.25 = $59.50, and Shopify on the $39 plan costs $39 + 14 x $1.46 = $59.44, effectively tied. At 13 orders ($520) Etsy wins, $55.25 against $57.98. At 15 orders ($600) Shopify wins, $63.75 against $60.90. On the $29 a month yearly plan the crossover is lower: $29 / $2.79 = about 10 orders a month, roughly $416 in sales.

The catch on both sides

  • Etsy brings traffic; Shopify brings none. Etsy shoppers arrive looking for handmade, vintage and craft supplies. A Shopify store starts with zero visitors, so add your own advertising, social or SEO budget to the Shopify column before you call it cheaper.
  • Shopify charges every month, even with zero sales. A slow month still costs $39 (or $29). Etsy costs nothing in a month with no sales, apart from $0.20 renewals on listings that have been live for four months.
  • Your average order changes the answer. This table uses a $40 average order. With a $15 average order, each Shopify order saves less and the crossover moves higher. With a $100 average order, it moves lower. Run your own average order through the calculators below.

The verdict

  • Under about $560 a month, Etsy is cheaper. No monthly fee beats a cheap per-order rate when you have few orders.
  • Over about $560 a month, Shopify is cheaper on fees, and the saving grows with every order: about $31 a month at $1,000 in sales, about $310 a month at $5,000.
  • On the $29 yearly plan, the crossover drops to about $416 a month. If you are sure you will stick with Shopify for a year, the yearly billing pays for itself quickly.
  • Do not switch on fees alone. If Etsy search brings you most of your buyers, the traffic is worth more than the fee saving. Many sellers keep Etsy for discovery and add Shopify later, once sales are steady.

Run your own numbers in the Etsy fee calculator and the Shopify profit calculator. For the other side of the same question, see Etsy vs Gumroad fees, or compare six more platforms in the reseller fee comparison.

Fees checked: November 2026

Fees last checked November 2026 against Etsy's and Shopify's published rates (US sellers). Shopify Basic $39 a month on monthly billing, $29 a month billed yearly; 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction with Shopify Payments. Estimates only. FeeWisely is not affiliated with Etsy, Inc. or Shopify Inc.

Questions sellers ask

At what sales level does Shopify become cheaper than Etsy?

At about 14 orders of $40 a month, roughly $560 in monthly sales, on the $39 a month Shopify Basic plan. On the $29 a month yearly plan the crossover is lower, about 10 orders a month or roughly $416 in sales. Below that, Etsy is cheaper.

How much does Etsy take per order?

About $4.25 on a $40 order: the $0.20 listing fee plus 6.5% transaction fee plus 3% + $0.25 payment processing, all on the order total. That is roughly 10.6% of the order.

Does Shopify charge a fee per sale?

With Shopify Payments there is no extra platform fee, just 2.9% + $0.30 card processing per transaction, plus the $39 a month plan fee ($29 a month billed yearly). Using another payment gateway adds up to 2% per sale.

Is Shopify better than Etsy?

On fees alone, yes, once you sell more than about $560 a month. But Etsy brings built-in shoppers and Shopify brings none, so you must add your own advertising or SEO budget on Shopify. Fees are only half the comparison.